The Office of the Chief Administrative Hearing Officer (OCAHO) has ordered Hartmann Studio, Inc. to pay a fine of over $600,000, which is one of the largest fines that it has ever assessed for I-9 form violations not involving the knowing employment of undocumented workers. The violations were all substantive paperwork violations – the employer failing to sign Section 2 of the I-9 form, failing to timely prepare or present I-9 forms, failing to ensure employees properly completed Section 1 of the I-9 form, and failing to properly complete Section 3 of the I-9 form. ICE sought over $800,000 in penalties based upon an error rate of approximately 90%. However, OCAHO determined Hartmann’s conduct was not as bad as employers in three other recent cases and lowered the amount.
Hiring Tips Blog

Company Fined $600,000 for I-9 Violations
Sep 1, 2015 | E-Verify Issues, Immigration Issues
Recent Posts
- U.S. District Judge Upholds Federal Preemption Over Minnesota State Drug Testing Law
- Mississippi: Indian Tribe Approves Referendum Regulating the “Possession, Production, and Distribution of Marijuana on Tribal Lands”
- Your Breath May Be Your Next ID: Study Says Nasal Patterns are as Unique as Fingerprints
- Robert Half Settles Background Check Suit for More than $2.2M
- Job Seeker Says Paycom Background Check Included Twin Brother’s Charges
Categories
- Background Check Compliance (102)
- Background Check Laws (59)
- Background Screening (43)
- Biometric Identification (4)
- Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (1)
- Credit Checks (32)
- Criminal History Check (180)
- Data Protection & Privacy (100)
- E-Verify Issues (74)
- Education Verification (7)
- Educational and Childcare Hiring (28)
- EEOC (48)
- Employer Negligence (36)
- Employment Screening (136)
- Fair Credit Reporting Act (109)
- Featured Posts (1)
- Financial Services Hiring (11)
- Healthcare Hiring (2)
- Hiring Legal Compliance (2)
- Home Services and Repairs Hiring (6)
- Human Resources & Benefits (26)
- Immigration Issues (87)
- IT and Data Security Hiring (11)
- Medical & Pharmaceutical Industry Hiring (9)
- Occupational Fraud (11)
- Pre-employment Drug Testing (186)
- Retail Hiring (14)
- Security Services Hiring (3)
- Social Media (32)
- Transportation Industry Hiring (20)
- Uncategorized (1)
- Wage History Checks (4)